Business Phone number and address FIRST NIAGARA BANK in Coleman St, 16 - Chatham - NY - Chatham, NY. View First Niagara Bank's address, public records, background check, and more for with Whitepages reverse phone lookup - know who is calling. Amy Rossi | Hagaman, New York | Vice President at First Niagara Bank | 29 connections | See Amy's complete profile on Linkedin and Bank. Old Chatham, NY. Rockwell told the young Warner "If your going to paint a picture, have first niagara bank chatham ny tell a story, otherwise don't bother painting", a lesson Warner never forgot. After last years Sean's Run, he was inspired to create a special painting that he would donate to the event organizers to use as part of their fund raising efforts. Their exact address is: Fairview Ave. Artist Tom Warner presents Mark D. If you want to pay them a visit, go to State Route Raffle tickets are available at the bank and will also be sold first niagara bank chatham ny day of the race at Chatham High School.